2019-20
Female: Kira Williams, Cross Country
Male, Daniel Leach, Soccer
2018-19
Female: Michelle Ferraino, Volleyball
Male: Noah Wygel, Baseball
2017-18
Female: Megan Ryder, Volleyball
Male: Austin Heroth, Men's Soccer
2016-17
Female: Jenna Putnam, Volleyball
Male: Wolfgang Reinke, Men's Soccer
2015-16
Female: Kaylee Robinson, Volleyball
Male: Zachary Hughes, Baseball
2014-15
Female: Elizabeth Hayward, Volleyball
Male: Chance Steele, Soccer
2013-14
Female: Emily Robinson, Volleyball Male: Cullen Beauregard, Baseball
2012-13
Female: Kate Nelson, Volleyball & Cherly Osborne, Basketball
Male: James DeJong, Soccer
2011-12
Female: Cassie Brancato, Volleyball
Male: Nicholas Natoli, Baseball
2010-11
Female: Tiana Lopez, Soccer
Male: Wes Clark, Baseball
2009-10
Female: Jenna Malagisi, Soccer
Male: Anthony Osorio, Baseball